How Different Distribution of Assortments on Worksites Influences Forwarder Performance in Coniferous Plantations

Forwarders often load logs organized in large piles by modified farm tractors, skidders, animals, other forwarders, etc., but currently, there are no studies on how the different concentrations of logs affect forwarder performance in terms of time consumption, productivity, and costs in forwarding operations. A study was conducted in three locations situated in Bulgaria (sites A and B) and in southern Italy (site C): in site A the logs were spread in the stand, in site B they were concentrated in large piles at the roadside, whereas in site C the logs were organized at the roadside in piles of medium size. The average forwarder productivity in site A obtained at an average forwarding distance of 1780 m, an average payload volume of 9.83 m3, and an average number of grips of logs with the crane grapple, during loading (22.97) and during unloading (8.97) per cycle, is 10.43 m3·PMH-1 (PMH, productive machine hour) and 9.93 m3·SMH-1 (SMH, scheduled machine hour), respectively. In site B the productivity rate was lower than that registered by the forwarder operated in site A: 9.38 m3·PMH-1 and 8.81 m3·SMH-1, respectively, at an average forwarding distance of 3760 m, average payload volume of 15.04 m3, and a mean number of grips of logs with the crane grapple, during loading and during unloading, of 23.57 and 14.10 per cycle, respectively. With regard to site C, the average machine productivitiy was 12.39 m3·PMH-1 and 11.85 m3·SMH-1, travelling a mean forwarding distance of 1630 m, transporting a mean load volume of 13.63 m3, and performing an average number of grips of logs with the crane grapple, during loading of 26.52 and during unloading of 12.36 per cycle. The ratio between the number of grips of logs with the crane grapple during loading and unloading operations in site A is on average 2.56, but in site B it is significantly smaller – mean of 1.67, due to the larger number of logs in the grapple when loading from large piles. Site C shows a loading and unloading number of grips ratio intermediate between the two Bulgarian sites. This ratio is characterized by the concentration of logs in the stand. Concentration in larger piles results in a larger volume of grappled logs by crane, and hence, lower time for loading of the forwarder and higher productivity. The obtained results show that the dispersion of small piles of logs results in a smaller volume grappled, a greater number of crane cycles and a larger loading distance, which generally, increases loading time. The larger volume of logs in the crane grapple and the shorter loading distance, when the loading operation is carried out from larger piles at the roadside, lead to less loading time. Gross costs for forwarders were 65.14 € PMH-1 at Site A, 72.96 €·PMH-1 at Site B, and 85.58 €·PMH-1 at Site C. When the forwarders were productive, the costs were 6.35 €·m-3 in site A, 7.90 €·m-3 in site B, and 6.90 €·m-3 in site C.